The coins on the market that are currently going for around $13,500 have President Dwight D. Eisenhower on their head. Like all other dollar coins, they also say "In God We Trust" on the head of ...

At her home in Moonachie, New Jersey, Quintero showed some of the coins that could have value: a few buffalo head nickels, an Eisenhower silver dollar, and at least one coin that dates back to 1887.